Stalking Jack The Ripper by Kerri Maniscalco // Yes, dear book, we know you’re gruesome. // Audrey Rose, dear, SHUT UP.

Stalking Jack the Ripper (Stalking Jack the Ripper, #1)
I adore this cover but it is RUINED by that tagline on the top. THANKS A LOT, JAMES PATTERSON.

Stalking Jack the Ripper by Kerri Maniscalco

Rating: 2 Stars

Release Date: September 20, 2016

Genre: YA Historical Fiction / Murder Mystery

Seventeen-year-old Audrey Rose Wadsworth was born a lord’s daughter, with a life of wealth and privilege stretched out before her. But between the social teas and silk dress fittings, she leads a forbidden secret life.

Against her stern father’s wishes and society’s expectations, Audrey often slips away to her uncle’s laboratory to study the gruesome practice of forensic medicine. When her work on a string of savagely killed corpses drags Audrey into the investigation of a serial murderer, her search for answers brings her close to her own sheltered world.

my thoughts graphic

I was so excited for this book it’s almost pathetic. Doesn’t it look fantastic?? A Victorian murder mystery about a creepy serial killer?? My excitement for Stalking Jack the Ripper tripled after reading The Diviners by Libba Bray and professing my undying love for it in this (shamelessly) self-promoted review. Sadly, I was disappointed in Stalking Jack the Ripper in almost every way.

I felt like this book was trying too hard. Too hard to make Audrey Rose a modern, feminist, (more on that in juuust a bit) too hard to make Thomas Cresswell charming and swoony, and too hard to make the story and villains creepy and unnerving. The result was a silly, over-dramatic story that could not hold my attention.

The characters all felt so two-dimensional. Audrey Rose had no personality except for her feminism. Cresswell could have been charming and swoony, but the extremely dramatic and overdone way in which his character was written just made him annoying. Also, I was not convinced at all of the instalovey romance between Audrey Rose and Cresswell. (Also, for some reason I can’t stop picturing him as a nerd wearing tiny glasses, which is really uncomfortable and NOT what the author intended. It’s quite awkward.) And the other characters were even more flat. None of them felt like real people; the relationship between Audrey Rose and her father felt contrived and cliche, the villain was comically evil, etc. I meanhe actually said things like, “I’m going to kill you, heehee!!” No joke. Basically, all the characters managed to be both extremely overdone personality wise AND underdeveloped characterization wise, which makes absolutely no sense.

random graphic

The plot could not hold my attention. I don’t know if that’s because the characters were so frustrating to me or if the story really is just boring. But I kind of dreaded coming back to this book because it was 1) really predictable, 2) dull, and 3) overly gruesome.

Look, the whole thing with Audrey Rose and her uncle dissecting bodies to find the killer was really quite clever. Except, there is a certain point where gruesome details start getting a little old. Maybe if the book had more substance in terms of characterization and plotting I wouldn’t have minded, but after a while the book felt like there was no point to it except for how gory it was.

And that ending. It was quite touching – or at least it would have been if I didn’t feel like I’d just had a bunch of fake sugar and sweetness and OH THE DRAMA shoved down my throat. (“I love you, you love me, we’re a happy familyyyy!!”) Plus, it was totally contrived and, based on the rest of the story, was not convincing at all.

random graphic

This next section is probably going to make me very unpopular – which is unfortunate, as it is just my opinion. But read ahead if you’d like!

My biggest issue with the book was Audrey Rose’s extremely unrealistic and forced feminism.

Because here’s the thing. It’s okay to make your heroine a feminist. But it is NOT okay to POUND THE READER OVER THE HEAD WITH AND SHOVE DOWN THEIR THROATS HOW MUCH OF A FEMINIST YOUR MAIN CHARACTER IS.

(Yes, I am quite perturbed at the moment.)

See, it’s one thing to make your heroine a feminist, but you don’t have to tell the reader 72365125 thousand times!! I felt like I constantly got into the story, only to be jerked out by a statement that wasn’t really necessary in that specific moment. It just got really annoying after a while.

Also, yes, feminism existed in the late 1800s – but not in the exact same way it does now. That’s why I like books like The Dark Days Club by Alison Goodman and These Shallow Graves by Jennifer Donnelly;  the female main characters of those books question the mindset of their times, and work to overcome that mindset themselves, which is much more realistic and infinitely more compelling. Sadly, Stalking Jack the Ripper did not have any of that character growth; it felt like Audrey Rose and her mindset had been plucked from the 21st century and transported to Victorian England.

random graphic

Back to the non-controversial part of my review!! Hooray!

This book isn’t all bad. It was entertaining (when it wasn’t aggravating) and I finished it, so that’s saying something. Also, it gave me a reason to be snarky, which I enjoy way too much.

talk to me page graphic

If you’re still here after that long and ranty review, have you read this book? What did you think about it? What is one thing that really frustrates you in a book?

Content Guide: There is only occasional light profanity, but this is definitely a book for older teens. It is frequently gory, and some fairly graphic and vivid details of dissected corpses and organs etc. are given.

10 thoughts on “Stalking Jack The Ripper by Kerri Maniscalco // Yes, dear book, we know you’re gruesome. // Audrey Rose, dear, SHUT UP.

  1. OH NOOOOO NO NO NO. This book seemed so fantastically enticing to me, but based on your recent rec to me (My Lady Jane), I am put off! Feminism must be treated carefully when you’re not in the modern times, and like okay cool you’re a feminist. What’s the so what, though?? Like what do you do. SHOW ME. Truly, actions (even written actions in a fictional story, lol) speak louder than words!!
    I have an infinite amount of fascination surrounding serial killers and murderers in general. I actually lost one of my family members to murder, so these stories have to be well-done for me. It’s so important and I might be overly critical because I’ve been personally affected, but I’ve been wary of YA fiction involving accurate portrayals of murder because of this. I have heard the the female of the species is very good though, so I might read that soon?? I DON’T KNOW.
    Thank you for the honest review, Lenna. I, for one, appreciate it! ❤

    Liked by 1 person

      I agree! It was different, and even if people don’t like that, it’s true!! Actions do speak louder than words.
      I’m really sorry to hear that!! I can see how that would make you really critical about how it’s portrayed. I think they’re fascinating too, which is one reason I was so disappointed in the villain’s characterization in this book.
      I haven’t read that but I’ve heard it’s really, really good! I hope you like it if you do try it.
      Aw, thank you!! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Just stopping by to say hi!! Found your blog through Marie’s SFATW feature.

    I’ve been hearing this book hyped up quite a bit, but based on your review it sounds like it’s pretty boring. Good character development is absolutely essential for when I’m reading something

    (Also I’m legit sad that you hate avocados like girl why?!!! D:)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, cool!! I’ll be sure to check out yours too!

      Yeah, it’s very important to me too! I was pretty disappointed :'(.

      Haha, I know, it’s weird. But they’re all mushy and slimy! :p


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s